| 1985 | Mark Dani | Lesley Noll |
| 1986 | Marc Davis | Darcy Arreola Laura Chapel |
| 1987 | Marc Davis | Kira Jorgensen |
| 1988 | Francis O'Neill Matt Farmer | Kira Jorgensen |
| 1989 | Francis O'Neill Brent Noon | Kira Jorgensen |
| 1990 | Brent Noon | Allison Dring |
| 1991 | Keith Green | Erin Blunt Allison Dring Milena Glusac |
| 1992 | Riley Washington | Erin Blunt Leslie Coons Milena Glusac |
| 1993 | Mark Hauser Mebrahtom Keflezighi Paul Turner | Milena Glusac Monique Henderson |
| 1994 | Mebrahtom Keflezighi Von Ware | Monique Henderson Tamieka Porter |
| 1995 | Mike Brown | Kristi Draher Lana Garner Monique Henderson |
| 1996 | Lydell Burston Felix Sanchez Vince Williams | Monique Henderson Akiba McKinney |
| 1997 | Reggie DePass Vili Makihala Thomas Mootry Tracy Smith | Andria Booker Monique Henderson Akiba McKinney Lisa Underhill |
| 1998 | Reggie DePass Cheyne Jones Darius Savage MLK Blasters Youth Boys | Andria Booker Monique Henderson |
| 1999 | Danny Ames Marcus Chandler | Kathleen Donoghue Monique Henderson Tracy O'Hara Vanessa Rivera |
| 2000 | Danny Ames Evan Fox Ryan Moorcroft Darius Savage | Kathleen Donoghue Monique Henderson |
| 2001 | Jeffrey Hunter | Monique Henderson Jenna Timinsky |
| 2002 | Reggie Bush DeSaan Hardwick Colby Peters Darius Savage | Monique Henderson Elizabeth Paxton Jenna Timinsky |
| 2003 | Brandon Bornes Jared Bray Brett Campfield Tyson Gray Derrell Hutsona | Claire Rethmeier |
| 2004 | Dax Danns Darren Fahy Darius Savage Daniel Schaerer | |
| 2005 | AJ Acosta Jesse O’Brien Darius Savage | Zaybree Haury |
